State Comparison

New York vs Illinois

By StateCalc Updated

New York is more expensive to live in than Illinois. Illinois costs about 29% less overall, with an index of 94.5 against 132.6 (C2ER Cost of Living Index, Q2 2026, via MERIC; 100 = national average). Housing explains much of the gap: Illinois's housing index is 83.3 against New York's 194.8.

Salary to match: NY to IL

On $85,820 in New York (its median household income), a single renter keeps $30,032 after taxes, rent, power and food; Illinois takes $70,100 to match ($15,700 less).

Rent is the widest gap: a one-bedroom lists at $2,303 a month in New York, $1,518 in Illinois ($9,420 a year). Then electricity: $354 a year less in Illinois.

A year New York Illinois, matched
Salary $85,820 $70,100
Federal tax + FICA $16,616 $11,955
State taxes on pay $4,439 $3,325
Take-home pay $64,765 $54,820
Rent, one-bedroom (HUD FY2027 FMR) $27,636 $18,216
Electricity (EIA 2024 average bill) $1,674 $1,320
Groceries (USDA Moderate, one adult) $5,423 $5,232
Left for everything else $30,032 $30,052

NY and IL pay, matched

Pay NY → IL IL → NY
$40,000 $26,900 $53,300
$60,000 $46,600 $74,600
$80,000 $64,600 $95,900
$100,000 $84,000 $116,200
$150,000 $132,700 $167,500

On $83,211 in Illinois (its median household income), a single renter keeps $38,627 after taxes, rent, power and food; New York takes $99,200 to match ($16,000 more).

15 rates and fees

Measure NY IL
Cost of Living Index 132.6 94.5
Typical Home Value $526,000 $299,000
2BR Fair Market Rent $2,565/mo $1,752/mo
Property Tax Rate 1.30% 1.88%
Top Income Tax Rate 10.90% 4.95%
Sales Tax Rate 4.00% 6.25%
Median Household Income $85,820 $83,211
Minimum Wage New York sets its rate by region (NYSDOL, checked 2026-10-20). $17.00/hr (NYC, Long Island & Westchester); $16.00/hr (the rest of the state) $15.00/hr
Max Unemployment Benefit $869/wk (claims through Oct 4, 2026) $628/wk
LLC Filing Fee $200 $150
LLC Annual Fee $9 $75
Avg Car Insurance $1,753/yr $1,153/yr
Avg Home Insurance $1,801/yr $1,480/yr
Transfer Tax Rate 0.40% 0.10%
Top Capital Gains Rate 10.90% 4.95%

Frequently Asked Questions

What salary in Illinois matches $85,820 in New York?

$70,100, about $15,700 less; either way about $30,000 a year is left.

What salary in New York matches $83,211 in Illinois?

$99,200, about $16,000 more; either way about $38,600 a year is left.

Monthly basics: New York or Illinois?

$2,064 in Illinois vs $2,894 in New York (rent, power, food).

Sources

Pay: Census ACS 2024 median household income; single filer, wages. Taxes: NY and IL paycheck engines. Rent: HUD FY2027 FMR. Power: EIA-861 bill. Food: USDA Moderate, C2ER grocery index. Matched pay is rounded to $100. Car, health and child care not counted.

Rates: C2ER Q2 2026 (MERIC), Zillow ZHVI June 2026, HUD two-bedroom FMR, U.S. DOL, NAIC 2023. Reviewed ; estimates, not tax advice.